In an attempt to help two different horses, Amy finds herself involved in the personal lives of their owners, one whom is her showjumping rival, Ashley Grant. When Ashley Grant shows up uninvited at Heartland, Amy is suspicious. Ashley has been anything but nice in the past, and now she is asking for a favor. She wants Amy to help train Bright Magic, a showy European jumper recently purchased by her mom. Despite Amy's cloudy relationship with the Grants, she accepts the challenge, knowing that helping horses is her first priority. And as Amy starts to work with Ashley, she is forced to see her bitter old rival in a whole new way.